mairead
|
2014 GAMES COME TO GLASGOWGreat news for a great city.
|
sgmillerton
|
well done indeed, a very positive thing for glasgow. can you imagine the outrge though when the king/queen are at the opening ceremony and a rousing rendition of gstq.
|
Cymro
|
Don't think there will be an outrage Sg. Most of Scotland still seems to be pro Monarchy. Also may republics (Nigeria being the other candidate included) are Republics but memebers of the Commonwealth. Would be interesting to see whether Republicans (in the true sense not the Northern Irish definition) support the Games though.
Certainly a good thing for Glasgow and will have a far better impact on sport in terms on investment than the Olympics will.
Shame football isn't in the games.
|
sgmillerton
|
i was being sarcy thats all but the more i think about it, it could be king billy at pakhead singing gstq and applauding for the ulster team and red hand banners. i'm sure you can see the funny side.
|
carol
|
It would be interesting to know what % of Sotland still supports the Monarchy. I wouldn't have thought most Cymro
It is excellent news Margaret, unfortunately my little one has hijacked the TV and it's cartoons that's been on most of the day
regards
Carol
|
Cymro
|
| sgmillerton wrote: | | i was being sarcy thats all but the more i think about it, it could be king billy at pakhead singing gstq and applauding for the ulster team and red hand banners. i'm sure you can see the funny side. |
Would Celtic Park be used?
|
Cymro
|
| carol wrote: | It would be interesting to know what % of Sotland still supports the Monarchy. I wouldn't have thought most Cymro
|
I wouldn't be suprised. In the very least people wouldn't care less if she was there or not. I'd say a minortity would be the people who actually gave a toss she was present and is head of the Monarchy. I myself prefer the Commonwealth Games to the Olympics.
|
Rinty
|
"it could be king billy at pakhead singing gstq and applauding for the ulster team and red hand banners. i'm sure you can see the funny side."
er, uslter dont have a team in the commonwelath games, you might be getting mixed up with rugby where the border that separates the counties of ulster doesnt exist in that sport. And red hands are flown at celtic park every week so whats the problem???? Parkie's band have a flag with a red hand of ulster on it, I saw it in a video at the GOMA.
BTW, does anyone else find it strange that miller, a supposed hibs fan, sees the commonwealth games not in a glasgow v edinburgh context but in an anti-celtic context? All he is interested in is whether a game will be at celtic park and whether GSTQ will be sung there. Somes hibs fan
|
Cymro
|
Doesn't look like Celtic Park or Ibrox are being used anyway. Shame in a way as it would be a good opportunity to show case both places for other compeitions.
|
Aventinian
|
| Rinty wrote: | | er, uslter dont have a team in the commonwelath games |
Hopelessly pedantic. Ulster does have a team, it's called Northern Ireland.
|
Rinty
|
???
Northern Ireland has a team yes but thats a bit like saying that america has a tyeam, it's called canada.
tb miller was referring to red hand banners. The red hand is an all uslter symbol that isnt exclusive to any side of the divide and applies equally to the three Ulster counties in the republic, Monaghan, Cavan and Donegal. So in that context it is hardly pedantic.
|
sgmillerton
|
| Rinty wrote: | "it could be king billy at pakhead singing gstq and applauding for the ulster team and red hand banners. i'm sure you can see the funny side."
er, uslter dont have a team in the commonwelath games, you might be getting mixed up with rugby where the border that separates the counties of ulster doesnt exist in that sport. And red hands are flown at celtic park every week so whats the problem???? Parkie's band have a flag with a red hand of ulster on it, I saw it in a video at the GOMA.
BTW, does anyone else find it strange that miller, a supposed hibs fan, sees the commonwealth games not in a glasgow v edinburgh context but in an anti-celtic context? All he is interested in is whether a game will be at celtic park and whether GSTQ will be sung there. Somes hibs fan  |
good lord, i was being light hearted it amuses me that (maybe) king billy will be opening the games at that bastion of commonweath and royalty. celtic park. hearing gstq being sung by 60,000 people in pakhead is funny. just the same as if eire played a game at ibrox in some way. seriously, take a chill pill.
|
sgmillerton
|
| Cymro wrote: | | Doesn't look like Celtic Park or Ibrox are being used anyway. Shame in a way as it would be a good opportunity to show case both places for other compeitions. |
both are being used. i'm not sure why parkhead is being used, i would have thought that for such a global event you would use the 2 best stadiums (both eufa 5 star) in glasgow.
|
mairead
|
ach well, meybe by then Scotland will be independent and the opening could go to the first minister who is in power then, or does Queenie go to open all the commonwealth games anyway?
|
iainmhor
|
Scotland out of the commonwealth by 2014. All hail the coming Scottish Republic.
|
sgmillerton
|
like australia amongst others?
|
Rinty
|
whats ibrox being used for?
parkhead is being used for the opening ceremony as it is seen as the best option to stage such an event, and it is next to the new indoor arena and the athletes village.
It may surprise you that UEFA dont organise the commonwealth games.
|
carol
|
Margaret she's head of the Commonwealth, I think she'd need to be there, not unless the monarchy's kicked out by then!
|
sgmillerton
|
| Rinty wrote: | whats ibrox being used for?
parkhead is being used for the opening ceremony as it is seen as the best option to stage such an event, and it is next to the new indoor arena and the athletes village.
It may surprise you that UEFA dont organise the commonwealth games. |
thanks, i did not know that.............mind you on the 2014 website it does trumpet the fact that the 2 stadiums where actual competition is being held are both uefa 5 star stadiums so the organisers are keen to let the world know.
ot does actually make sense for the opening ceremony at parkhead due to geography.
the rugby is being held at ibrox, i suspect the bean counters at rangers will be cashing in on the fact that the ozzies and the likes will be at ibrox and will market this to rangers advantage to the full.
|
Aventinian
|
| Rinty wrote: | ???
Northern Ireland has a team yes but thats a bit like saying that america has a tyeam, it's called canada. |
Not really, since Ulster is commonly used as a synonym for Northern Ireland.
Rather like saying the UK has a time, it's called Great Britain.
|
Aventinian
|
| mairead wrote: | | ach well, meybe by then Scotland will be independent and the opening could go to the first minister who is in power then, or does Queenie go to open all the commonwealth games anyway? |
Maybe Scotland won't exist by then and it will be opened by Prime Minister Obama of the new Anglo-American Imperium.
|
sgmillerton
|
| Aventinian wrote: | | mairead wrote: | | ach well, meybe by then Scotland will be independent and the opening could go to the first minister who is in power then, or does Queenie go to open all the commonwealth games anyway? |
Maybe Scotland won't exist by then and it will be opened by Prime Minister Obama of the new Anglo-American Imperium. |
hahahahaha, brilliant sir.
|
Cymro
|
| sgmillerton wrote: | | Cymro wrote: | | Doesn't look like Celtic Park or Ibrox are being used anyway. Shame in a way as it would be a good opportunity to show case both places for other compeitions. |
both are being used. i'm not sure why parkhead is being used, i would have thought that for such a global event you would use the 2 best stadiums (both eufa 5 star) in glasgow. |
Not according to the BBC. They only mention Hampden. Isn't Celtic only 4* - something to do with the changing room being too small? Or was that Ibrox?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/glasgow_and_west/6510105.stm
|
Cymro
|
| mairead wrote: | | ach well, meybe by then Scotland will be independent and the opening could go to the first minister who is in power then, or does Queenie go to open all the commonwealth games anyway? |
She's head of the Commonwealth so yes, she attends anyway.
| iainmhor wrote: | | Scotland out of the commonwealth by 2014. All hail the coming Scottish Republic. |
Not necessarily, a Republic can still remain as part of the Commonwealth - India, Pakistan, South Africa, Bangladesh, Fiji, Nigeria, Ghana etc are all republics. They just accept the Queen is head of the Commonwealth.
|
sgmillerton
|
| Cymro wrote: | | sgmillerton wrote: | | Cymro wrote: | | Doesn't look like Celtic Park or Ibrox are being used anyway. Shame in a way as it would be a good opportunity to show case both places for other compeitions. |
both are being used. i'm not sure why parkhead is being used, i would have thought that for such a global event you would use the 2 best stadiums (both eufa 5 star) in glasgow. |
Not according to the BBC. They only mention Hampden. Isn't Celtic only 4* - something to do with the changing room being too small? Or was that Ibrox?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/glasgow_and_west/6510105.stm |
the bbc are wrong. celtic actually have no stars for their stadium. uefa only have 4 and 5 star stadiums all around capacity, disabled access, press space, changing rooms, quality of ground etc etc.
i'll see if i can find something at uefa or something.
|
sgmillerton
|
that was easy, i suspect that this is why the bid only wanted to use the 5 star stdiums for sporting events which makes sense.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Stadia_List
|
will live from Glasgow
|
i am extremely happy that Glasgow got the commonwealth games,though in my mind there was never any doubt that we would. Apart from the simple opportunity of being able to show off our city on the world stage it will mean a legacy of new facilities and other projects that will be of use long after 2014.
If Scotland were to become independent there is no question in my mind that we would remain part of the commonwealth,
From the commonwealth of nations website:"The Commonwealth is a voluntary association of 53 independent sovereign states consulting and co-operating in the common interests of their peoples and in the promotion of international understanding and world peace."
now who could possibly be against that?
as far as the monarchy goes the understood SNP platform is that if their was public demand there would be a referendum to decide whether scotland becomes a republic,and this of course would have absolutlely nothing to do with member ship of the commonwealth.
Because the monarchy doesnt actually have an impact on people's everyday lives,and we live in a liberal democracy where they couldnt even if they wanted to, i dont think there will be much demand for getting rid of them, its not that people support them,its just that they dont oppose them that much.
|
iainmhor
|
| Cymro wrote: | | mairead wrote: | | ach well, meybe by then Scotland will be independent and the opening could go to the first minister who is in power then, or does Queenie go to open all the commonwealth games anyway? |
She's head of the Commonwealth so yes, she attends anyway.
| iainmhor wrote: | | Scotland out of the commonwealth by 2014. All hail the coming Scottish Republic. |
Not necessarily, a Republic can still remain as part of the Commonwealth - India, Pakistan, South Africa, Bangladesh, Fiji, Nigeria, Ghana etc are all republics. They just accept the Queen is head of the Commonwealth. |
Aye but my point is we leave this vestige of British Empire, colonialism and imperialism. Just like the ROI.
|
Cymro
|
I quite like the Commomwealth to be honest. There was talk a few years ago of the RoI joining the Commonwealth as a Republic alongside India etc. Was bought up as part of the Good Friday Agreement. Went nowhere though as neither side (the British Government, the Irish Government, Republicans and Unionists) saw it as that important for the Agreement to go through.
|
Aventinian
|
| iainmhor wrote: | Aye but my point is we leave this vestige of British Empire, colonialism and imperialism. Just like the ROI.  |
Ah, the "World's bitterest small country".
Really, emulating Ireland in terms of national insecurity and cultural imperialism is the very last thing I think anyone other than the extreme nationalist lunatics like yourself want to see.
|
Babygael
|
The world's bitterest small country??????????????????
And why would that be ave darlin'? Goat ony reasons?
My feeling is that ony country that hud tae accomodate a Foreign country
I guess that might just cause some BITTERNESS after 300 yrs
There is something that I never asked of you Ave, and that is...... Do you care for scotlands heros?
Scots as a race?
Do you see scotland as a Country in it's own right as it was ?
Do you despise your own race?
Do you care that so many of yours and my ancestors died in Battle to preserve Scotland from the saxon barstewards??
Do you care for the scots warriors who lay burried at Culloden and on so many other battle fields since ?
Does it matter to you that some of these might be your own anccestors?
Do you care at all?
Are you a traitor to your 'ain folk and country?
Do you know what we think of folk like you?
I guess not.
|
agentmancuso
|
| Babygael wrote: |
... scotlands heros...
...Scots as a race...
... your own race ...
... ancestors died in Battle...
... saxon barstewards...
...scots warriors...
... battle fields since...
... your own anccestors...
...a traitor to your 'ain folk and country...
Do you know what we think of folk like you?
|
I think you are a racist crank.
|
sgmillerton
|
| Babygael wrote: | The world's bitterest small country??????????????????
And why would that be ave darlin'? Goat ony reasons?
My feeling is that ony country that hud tae accomodate a Foreign country
I guess that might just cause some BITTERNESS after 300 yrs
There is something that I never asked of you Ave, and that is...... Do you care for scotlands heros?
Scots as a race?
Do you see scotland as a Country in it's own right as it was ?
Do you despise your own race?
Do you care that so many of yours and my ancestors died in Battle to preserve Scotland from the saxon barstewards??
Do you care for the scots warriors who lay burried at Culloden and on so many other battle fields since ?
Does it matter to you that some of these might be your own anccestors?
Do you care at all?
Are you a traitor to your 'ain folk and country?
Do you know what we think of folk like you?
I guess not. |
a tremendous outburst.
|
Aventinian
|
BG: Scots are not a race, and even if they were I couldn't care less. I am not a racist.
|
SLG
|
I think the whole thing is a bit of a waste of money. I can't believe we have to wait until we get the chance to host a sporting event before we can come up with the money to try and regenerate areas of deprivation. Will the Commonwealth sporting village (or whatever it's called) end up as the type of housing we want in that area? I also don't think that from a sporting point of view, building the new venues is a good way to spend the little money we have.
I think that politically, it is good news for Salmond as it will be perceived as a success for him - or more importantly, would have been perceived as a personal failure if Glasgow had not won.
|
Cymro
|
Can't agree with that SLG. Yes, it's sad that they have to wait for this sort of thing before regenerating an area which clearly needs it. However I'd imagine hosting one of the worlds main sporting events releases a hell of a lot of funding - public and private that wouldn't be available otherwise.
I gather the Athletes Village will be developed into housing after the games are over. Not knowing the area I can imagine there is some need for housing, either to replace those all ready there or to cater for an expanding city. It is obviously important that this development is intergrated into the existing communities and not as a new ghetto and therefore important that the area is affordable for people who all ready live in the area.
Economically it will be huge for Scotland, even if it's just from the journalists, fans, families, dignatories and competitors all staying and spending money in the area. When Wales hosted the Rugby World Cup in 1999 loads of developments took place - Millenium Stadium built instead of the old National Stadium, my local club, Wrexham FC's ground was redeveloped inorder to host some rugby matches, new hotels opened. After the games finished the FA Cup, League Cup and Play Offs where played at the Mill Stad as Wembley was being redone as well as Rugby League and Union matches, huge concerts and boxing matches (and other stuff). If it wasn't for the RWC these wouldn't have come.
It's also a good way of showing off a new Scotland. Something which the SNP would be putting a lot of work into I'd imagine.
|
SLG
|
Why does it take this event to release the funding though? What would happen to that money if the games weren't coming to Glasgow? Aye, there will be some private funding through advertising that wouldn't otherwise be there, but I'm not sure that is enough to compensate for the public money that will be written off after the event.
Regarding the housing, it may well work. Again, I just can't help assuming that the housing will be designed to meet the needs of the competitors, media etc. Not the needs of a deprived urban community. Maybe they can marry the two, I'll be impressed if they can though. That said, the quality of housing developments here is poor as it is, so this probably can't be any worse.
I've no doubt that over all it will be good for the east end of Glasgow and beyond. My point is about value for money. We're going to spend £300m odd on this - probably well over that. We could spend half that on the developments that we really need, and the rest, we could use to cover 'lost revenues' by not hosting the event. I think if we did that, we would save money overall and could spend it elsewhere.
|
sgmillerton
|
i was thinking this today, it's all very well aying this be community housing after the games but as we know 'community housing' is just another name for where the bams end up. how often is it said, 'oh those new/redevolped houses look nice' until the local authorities put into them the same bams back into them who turned the place into hell in the first place.
|
Celtic Indian
|
Great news for the community of Dalmarnock.One of the poorest in the UK.
Budget currently stands at £298m.Lets see how high it gets.
|
Cymro
|
| SLG wrote: | Why does it take this event to release the funding though? What would happen to that money if the games weren't coming to Glasgow? Aye, there will be some private funding through advertising that wouldn't otherwise be there, but I'm not sure that is enough to compensate for the public money that will be written off after the event.
Regarding the housing, it may well work. Again, I just can't help assuming that the housing will be designed to meet the needs of the competitors, media etc. Not the needs of a deprived urban community. Maybe they can marry the two, I'll be impressed if they can though. That said, the quality of housing developments here is poor as it is, so this probably can't be any worse.
I've no doubt that over all it will be good for the east end of Glasgow and beyond. My point is about value for money. We're going to spend £300m odd on this - probably well over that. We could spend half that on the developments that we really need, and the rest, we could use to cover 'lost revenues' by not hosting the event. I think if we did that, we would save money overall and could spend it elsewhere. |
I'd imagine the Atheltes Village will be temporary structures and will be flattened to make way for the housing.
Of course it's a shame areas have to wait for this sort of event before they get the regeneration they deserve but I'm sure when it comes to hosting these sort of things it's easier to justify it. Especially when it comes to the Sporting stuff which will be coming. They will only build them if they have an opportunity to show them off to the world. This is a good opportunity.
The money bought in my tourism will be something that wouldn't be as easy otherwise. The money spent would be immense in Glasgow and surrounding areas as far as Edinburgh.
It's important in terms of the support of the population that the budget doesn't keep rising, but I do feel that it's a hell of a good opportunity for Scotland and Glasgow.
|
Aventinian
|
| SLG wrote: | | I think that politically, it is good news for Salmond as it will be perceived as a success for him - or more importantly, would have been perceived as a personal failure if Glasgow had not won. |
He's certainly been trying to latch on to it. No doubt if it is a disaster, however, Jack McConnell will be the man to get the blame.
|
Cymro
|
| Aventinian wrote: | | SLG wrote: | | I think that politically, it is good news for Salmond as it will be perceived as a success for him - or more importantly, would have been perceived as a personal failure if Glasgow had not won. |
He's certainly been trying to latch on to it. No doubt if it is a disaster, however, Jack McConnell will be the man to get the blame. |
Listening to Clyde 2 on the day the announcment was made I heard either Salmond or Sturgeon congratulating McConnell on starting the work off of trying to get the Commonwealth Games.
|
SLG
|
| Aventinian wrote: | | He's certainly been trying to latch on to it. No doubt if it is a disaster, however, Jack McConnell will be the man to get the blame. |
If it had failed, I'm sure he would have been held partly responsible. It was a success, so he'll take some of the credit. Given that he's a politician, of course he's going to try and milk it. Would you really expect anything less?
| Cymro wrote: | | Listening to Clyde 2 on the day the announcment was made I heard either Salmond or Sturgeon congratulating McConnell on starting the work off of trying to get the Commonwealth Games. |
Yes, that was one of the things I picked up on as well. Seemed like he was making a particular effort to give credit to McConnell.
|
agentmancuso
|
| SLG wrote: | | Seemed like he was making a particular effort to give credit to McConnell. |
It's a sensible move. Labour's relentless negativity cost them dearly at the last election; Salmond comes across as much more statesmanlike by being seen to be giving credit where it's due.
|
Cymro
|
| agentmancuso wrote: | | SLG wrote: | | Seemed like he was making a particular effort to give credit to McConnell. |
It's a sensible move. Labour's relentless negativity cost them dearly at the last election; Salmond comes across as much more statesmanlike by being seen to be giving credit where it's due. |
Exactly. It would have done the SNP more damage than good to have been seen to be ignoring the work of the previous government. Though obviously the likes of Avetinan won't change the habbits of a lifetime and allow the truth to get in the way of a bit of Nat Bashing!
|
sgmillerton
|
| agentmancuso wrote: | | SLG wrote: | | Seemed like he was making a particular effort to give credit to McConnell. |
It's a sensible move. Labour's relentless negativity cost them dearly at the last election; Salmond comes across as much more statesmanlike by being seen to be giving credit where it's due. |
jack mconnel is considerably more staesman like than slippry salmon in my view.
|
agentmancuso
|
| sgmillerton wrote: | | jack mconnel is considerably more staesman like than slippry salmon in my view. |
I'd be very surprised if many Labour MSPs/MPs shared that opinion, in private.
|
sgmillerton
|
no doubts. i'm quite certain the situation is similar in snp, tory and whatever ranks in terms of their leader.
|
mairead
|
Joke macConnell !!!Statesman like!!!.
Aye when he was wearing his wooly pin striped skirt in America he sure looked like a statesman-NOT.
If that is the best example of a statesman you can think of, Lord help us. He was a squirming, slease ball of a politician, with a forked tongue, to boot..
|
William_Cleland
|
| Rinty wrote: | ???
Northern Ireland has a team yes but thats a bit like saying that america has a tyeam, it's called canada.
|
Did Germany cease to be Germany when it lost East Prussia, a large chuck of Pomerania and Silesia post-1945? In reality the boundaries of Ulster have varied markedly through the centuries and it is a bit puzzling why Irish nationalists have such a strong apparent attachment to a set of county and provincial boundaries, which were actually determined in London to a large extent after the Battle of Kinsale and the Flight of the Earls.
|
|
|