Our Scotland - www.our-scotland.org

Blackleaf · Last edited by Blackleaf on Thu May 08, 2008 5:10 pm; edited 3 times in total

Will Scotland be able to cope as an independence state? "NO!", says the Daily Mail...

What if Scotland DID become independent? A historian looks forward 20 years and imagines the future

By ANDREW ROBERTS
8th May 2008
Daily Mail

The Scottish Labour leader, Wendy Alexander, called this weekend for an early referendum on Scottish independence - even though her party previously opposed the idea.

The move is seen as an attempt to wrong-foot Alex Salmond's Scottish National Party, which is committed to a referendum in 2010.

But many say her challenge could backfire and that the SNP could benefit from any poll result that suggests a move towards independence.

So what would an independent Scotland be like? Here, historian ANDREW ROBERTS looks forward to the year 2025 and imagines ...

The new Prime Minister frowned as he stared across the Cabinet table at the embarrassed looking Scottish High Commissioner. Had he heard correctly? Was President Salmond really asking that Scotland be re-admitted into the UK, after only 15 years as an independent state?

Cry freedom: But would independence work?

On-the-brink Brown faces fresh accusations of dithering - this time over a referendum on Scottish independence

They had been tumultuous years, of course, and 'the Tartan Revolt' had endured its ups and downs - mostly downs.

But was the Scottish Nationalist Party genuinely proposing to abolish itself, admitting the whole experiment had been a disastrous failure?

"I shall have to confer with the Cabinet, of course," the Prime Minister said.

Barely able to growl "Thank you, Mr Osborne", with a twist of his kilt the High Commissioner left.

The Rt Hon George Osborne MP, who had just returned from an audience at Buckingham Palace with King Charles III, sat back in his armchair in the middle of the Cabinet room and ruminated on the Scots' predicament.

Where had it all gone wrong? Of course, the 11-year-long international court case over who owned North Sea oil had been a serious blow to Scottish hopes when the 30 per cent share they were finally awarded turned out to have almost run dry anyhow.

The way that the English coastline jutted out into the North Sea and the Irish Sea just south of the border had persuaded the judges that was a generous settlement under international maritime law, but it seriously undermined Scottish Prime Minister Wendy Alexander's first term in office at Holyrood.

Then there was the termination of the annual Westminster subsidies to Scotland under the Barnett Formula, which in 2007 had amounted to £11.3 billion.

This ended overnight when the Scots voted - by 54 per cent to 46 per cent - for independence back in January 2010.

The ending of this £2,200-per-person subsidy meant the Holyrood Parliament in Edinburgh had to make severe cuts in public services, which rapidly became deeply unpopular.

Born blue: Mel Gibson as William Wallace in Braveheart

The removal of every Scottish MP in Westminster had also come as a body blow to New Labour, which was trying desperately to hang on until the last minute before calling a General Election in the early summer of 2010.

Gordon Brown was forced to give up the premiership, since his own seat of Kirkcaldy disappeared under the new constitution. Many in his party - possibly including himself - thought his resignation something of a blessing.

Earl Brown of Cowdenbeath, as he subsequently became, turned out to be one of the shortest-serving premiers of modern times.

David Miliband did his best to lead a minority government without the 39 Scottish MPs at Westminster, but the task proved beyond him. Not wishing to spend his life in perpetual opposition, he took up a post in the City.

Any hopes that the more Anglophobic Scots might have had that their defection would harm the UK were dashed when it kept its name - in reference to the English, Welsh and Northern Ireland components - as well as its seats in the UN Security Council, Nato, EU, OECD and other international bodies.

Scotland on its own, however, swiftly found itself with a voice somewhere between that of Serbia and Cyprus in weight, representing only 4.6 million people (after half-a-million English and business people emigrated to avoid the anti-sassenach legislation and high corporation taxes).

The decision of the Royal Bank of Scotland in 2018 to relocate its head office for tax purposes to the Square Mile was a stark indication of how bad things had got.

After the failure of the Tartan Pound, and the Scots refusal to peg their currency to sterling, their decision to join the euro had also been damaging - not least because it meant they no longer had any significant input into decisions over interests rates and liquidity.

On the Queen's death, aged 95, in 2021, the Scots compounded their error by joining Australia in becoming a republic.

It was not simply King Charles III's sale to Sir Billy Connolly of Balmoral and Birkhall, but also the sense that - as with Ireland in 1949 - the act to become a republic had been primarily anti-British in intent.

The phrases that the British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson had directed towards 'North Britain' had only inflamed opinion further.

In retrospect, the decision to move the naval base from Rosyth to a port south of the border was a natural one for a Westminster government determined to safeguard the interests of national security.

So, too, was the abolition of the remaining Scots regiments, despite their ancient and glorious history as part of the British Army.

The unemployment that resulted north of the Border may have been soaked up had the Scottish economy been growing, but the SNP-Labour coalition that ran the country under President Salmond and Prime Minister Wendy Alexander made an error in choosing that moment to push through radical land policies.

When tenants were given the right to buy their own homes, it was hoped by the Left that the landed estates of the Scottish aristocracy would be dispossessed in a generation or two, and there would be more fairness and opportunity in the glens.

What, in fact, happened was that the aristocratic estates did, indeed, disappear, but with them went the enterprises that allowed sports such as shooting, stalking and fishing to flourish.

The great sporting estates that had attracted tourist revenue to the Scottish Exchequer in George Square, Edinburgh, were no longer productive.

Expertise built up over the decades was lost, and farms were broken up into smaller and smaller units, many of which could no longer operate.

Tourists stopped bringing their euros, dollars, yen and Chinese yuan because, paradoxically, independence had robbed the country not only of its ancient rural traditions but of its confidence and grandeur.

To visitors, Scotland no longer felt genuinely Scottish. It had turned into just another small, unremarkable European country.

It all got progressively worse with the loss of whisky revenues after the declaration of independence from the Orkney and Shetland Islands.

By the time Alex Salmond became president, his country was unravelling, and the English border towns such as Berwick-upon-Tweed that had voted to join Scotland - in order to take advantage of social benefits in the good old Barnett Formula days (not for any actual love for Scotland) - were soon begging for re-admittance into the UK.

The Time magazine cover story - 'Tartan Nightmare' - was a turning point in the Scots' self-esteem, especially when it equated the chances of a successful independent Scotland with those of seeing the Loch Ness Monster.

It was with no sense of schadenfreude that Prime Minister Osborne took the decision that was plain to him as soon as the High Commissioner had left.

Of course, he would consult with the King, his own predecessor as premier Lord Cameron of Whitney and Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, but he was pretty certain that they would agree with his conclusion.

The answer must be 'No'. The Scots had chosen their destiny, and now they must live with it.

dailymail.co.uk

Lord Pitsligo · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 5:02 pm Post subject:

A candidate for dumbest newspaper article of the year?

Check the online comments at http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/...cle_id=564669&in_page_id=1770

Not too many people seem impressed by it.
_________________
"Grace Me Guide"

Blackleaf · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 5:12 pm Post subject:

Most of the people who weren't impressed by it were probably Scots, or a few English people who wanted to see Scotland go so England would be at least £11 billion a year a better off.

otherwise, an intelligent article which just highlights what could - or WILL - happen to an independent Scotland.

Scary stuff for you all.

Blackleaf · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 5:18 pm Post subject:

Lord Pitsligo · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 6:22 pm Post subject:

agentmancuso · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 6:54 pm Post subject:

I like this bit:

Alasdair · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 7:20 pm Post subject:

Well, obviously an accurate reflection for the future of Scotland ... except they missed the bit about Salmond fathering Alexander's next batch of offspring Rolling Eyes

I hate that bloody 'news'paper Mad

_________________
"We look to Scotland for all our ideas of civilisation." - Voltaire

Reluctant Hero · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 7:33 pm Post subject:

If Scotland was independent, I can just imagine the headlines in the Daily Mail in 20 years time:

"Can We Have Scotland Back"

"We Didn't Mean It"

or headlines to that effect.
_________________
Visit the Our Scotland Blog at http://our-scotland.blogspot.com/

Aventinian · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 7:42 pm Post subject:

The Daily Mail really is getting worse. It'll be on Daily Express levels soon.
_________________
The resident pantomime villain.
'Socialists cry "Power to the people", and raise the clenched fist as they say it. We all know what they really mean—power over people, power to the State.'

Tamed by a Scotsman · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 9:01 pm Post subject:

I came across that article in the paper and my first thought was "Oh no. But let's at least give it a try, it might at least try discussing the situation."

First line ... "Oh dear. Another journalist / historian who really wants to be a novelist but has no talent for it so they stick to better paid professions."

Second line ... "OK this is just stupid. Don't they realise that national pride and self respect are fundamental reasons for wanting to be independent? The people would not stop rioting if politicians sold them out a second time. And it's not likely to be Alex Salmond. Oh I can't be bothered reading this rubbish. Let's move to the last line."

Last line ... "As expected."
_________________
"They may take our lives, but they'll never take our tablet!"

azzuri · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 9:41 pm Post subject:

...dailymail.co.uk?, never!!!
_________________
"Every single person on this planet is unique. Just like everyone else..." - Random Guy in Edinburgh Pub

"There is British nationalism or Scottish nationalism. I prefer the civic nationalism of small nations that has been expressed through the independence of a dozen European nations of similar size to Scotland in the past 100 years. They have prospered and I'd choose the tolerance and peace of Norway and Ireland over Trident and the illegal Iraq war any day. - Alex Salmond

Possibly the funniest site in the world, 'The Daily Mash' - http://www.thedailymash.co.uk/

Aventinian · Posted: Thu May 08, 2008 11:47 pm Post subject:

Lord Pitsligo · Posted: Fri May 09, 2008 6:51 am Post subject:

agentmancuso · Posted: Fri May 09, 2008 6:52 am Post subject:

chicmac · No Longer a Wean Joined: 18 Mar 2008 Posts: 99

Lord Pitsligo · Posted: Fri May 09, 2008 6:21 pm Post subject:

Lewis · No Longer a Wean Joined: 21 Feb 2008 Posts: 80

Again, I fail to see that newspaper as being very intellectual. IO think that Scotland can survive both ways and it is merely opinion. Frankly nobody can predict what would happen if we were to become independent, but I'd be happy to be out of the UK.
_________________
Hammish Independence

mal · No Longer a Wean Joined: 15 Sep 2005 Posts: 93

I like the thought of being a wee country, making and standing by its own efforts, not worrying about pretentious delusions of greatness and grandour, looking after its own and helping where it can others who are less fortunate,having a democracy where the people are soveriegn and referees are unbiased Very Happy

Alasdair · Posted: Sat May 10, 2008 7:48 pm Post subject:

doodells · Posted: Thu May 15, 2008 11:41 pm Post subject:

A daft article IMO, it just shows all the aspiring journalists out there that there is a strong chance of getting your writings published no matter how bad you are. On a more serious level, people actually continue to buy the paper!!
_________________
"Scotland alone remains the ragged trousered philanthropist of petroleum economies."